Is Book of the Month Worth It? An Honest Review

Is Book of the Month Worth It?

If you’re looking to build a consistent reading routine or simply want a fun ay to discover new titles Book of the Month might be just what you need. With early access to buzzy new releases, handpicked recommendations across different genres, and a streamlined subscription model, it’s become a go-to for readers who want to stay on top of what’s new and noteworthy without spending hours scrolling reviews.

But like any subscription service, it comes with questions: Is it worth the cost? Will I actually use it? Is it the right fit for my reading habits? In this post, I’m breaking down everything you need to know about Book of the Month — how it works, what it costs, and the key benefits so you can decide if it’s right for you.

An Introduction to Book of the Month

Book of the Month is a monthly book subscription service that highlights new and early-release titles across a range of genres. Each month, their team selects a curated list of five to seven books, and members choose one title to receive in the mail. If you want to add on more than one book, you can for a discount price. 

What sets Book of the Month apart is its focus on discovery. Their selections often include new authors, early releases from popular authors, hidden gems, and other popular books you might not have come across your own. Whether you’re a casual reader or an avid bookworm, the experience feels personalized and low-pressure.

PSSST… Get your first month of Book of the Month for just $5!

How Does Book of the Month Subscription Work?

The process is super simple and user-friendly. 

Choose Your Book

On the first of each month, BOTM releases their new selections. You’ll get a short description of each book along with insights into the genre and themes. There are always great books to pick from each month and BOTM just rolled out options for both physical books and audiobooks.

Make Your Pick (or Skip!)

Select your book, or skip the month entirely if nothing calls your name. There’s no pressure or penalty for skipping, which makes the subscription feel flexible and low-commitment. Your credit will move to the following month.

Add Extras, If You Like

You can add up to two additional books to your box for a reduced price, including past favorites or add-ons from the current list

Enjoy the Read

Your hardcover book(s) will arrive at your doorstep in the BOTM signature blue packaging.

Skip Any Month, No Strings Attached

Life gets busy, and BOTM gets that. If you’re not feeling any of the books in the monthly book selection or simply want to pause, you can skip a month with one click. It’s a great option if you’re traveling, behind on your reading list, or just want to take a breather. Skipping also ensures you’re only paying for books you’re genuinely excited to read. When you skip, your credit for that month will carry over to the next month.

Book of the Month Pricing & Membership Options

Book of the Month keeps its pricing simple and affordable. 

  • Monthly membership: $17.99/month for one hardcover book
  • Add-on books: $10.99/additional book (up to two per month)
  • First box offer: New members can get their first book for just $5 here

There are no hidden fees, and you can skip a month any time without being charged. You can also cancel your subscription at any time.

Book of the Month Review
Honest Review of Book of the Month

Benefits of Book of the Month

Discover New Genres and Authors

One of the biggest perks of Book of the Month is how it encourages readers to step outside of their comfort zone. With a rotating selection of genres, from thriller and historical fiction to memoirs, contemporary fiction, and literary fiction, you’ll likely find yourself picking up books you wouldn’t normally reach for. It’s a low-risk, high-reward way to diversify your reading list.

Encourages a Consistent Reading Habit

Having a new book delivered to your doorstep each month is the perfect motivation to carve out more reading time. Whether you’re hoping to unplug in the evenings or build a morning reading ritual, BOTM helps you stay on track.

Early Access to Anticipated Titles

Many of Book of the Month’s picks are early releases or buzzy debuts that haven’t hit bookstore shelves yet. If you love being the friend who’s always reading the next big thing, this feature alone might make the membership worth it.

High-Quality Books at a Discounted Price

A hardcover booker $17.99 (or less, if it’s your first box) is a deal, especially considering that most new releases are priced $28+. The add-on pricing is also a steal, making it a great way to build a home library or gift a favorite to a friend.

Book of the Month BFF Status

One of the lesser-known (but super fun) perks of being a BOTM member is their relationship status rewards. The more boxes you receive, the closer you get to earning extra benefits, and who doesn’t love being rewarded for reading?

Here’s how BOTM club works:

  • New Member – Everyone stats here! You’ll get access to the monthly selection and can start building your home library.
  • Friend – Once you’ve been a member for 12 boxes (doesn’t have to be consecutive!), you become a friend. This unlocks early access to special add-ons and surprise bonuses throughout the year,
  • BFF – This is the highest level of membership and comes with the best perks, including a free book of the year pick, access to BFF-exclusive add-ons, and a birthday month book credit to treat yourself. 

Your relationship is tracked in your account, and it’s a sweet little milestone to look forward to, especially for long-term members who love a good bookish reward.

Excellent Customer Service (Just in Case)

Another reason Book of the Month stands out? Their customer service is top-tier. Whether you need help with a damaged book, want to double-check your shipment, or have questions about your membership, their team is super responsive and helpful. It’s so easy to get support via email or chat, and issues are always resolved quickly. It’s a small detail, but it makes the whole experience feel that much. More thoughtful and reliable.

So, Is Book of the Month Worth It?

If you’re an avid reader, enjoy discovering new books, or need help staying consistent with your reading goals, Book of the Month is absolutely worth it. The price point is reasonable and the monthly picks are thoughtfully curated. I also love how flexible it is, making it a great option for a wide range of book lovers. 

Whether you’re a seasoned reader or just getting back into the groove, Book of the Month is one of the best book subscriptions to help you stay inspired. I’ve had my BOTM subscription for since September 2019, and is one of the ways I’ve discovered some of my favorite books. Happy reading!

PSSST… Get your first month of Book of the Month for just $5!